John Robert Magaro (born February 16, 1983) is an American actor. He starred in the films Not Fade Away and First Cow. He also had supporting roles in Unbroken, The Big Short, Carol, Overlord and the Netflix series Orange Is the New Black and The Umbrella Academy. He made his Broadway debut as Earl Williams, the escaped convict, in the hit revival of The Front Page in 2016.
2026The Bride! as Unknown
2025The Mastermind as Fred
2025Materialists as Mark P. (voice)
2025Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer as Keane
2025Köln 75 as Keith Jarrett
2025Omaha as Dad
2024The Agency: Central Intelligence (10 Episodes) as Owen Taylor
2024Day of the Fight as Patrick
2024September 5 as Geoffrey Mason
2024LaRoy, Texas as Ray
2023Under the Boardwalk as Manny (voice)
2023The Mistress as Parker
2023Past Lives as Arthur
2023Big George Foreman as Desmond
2023Showing Up as Sean
2022Call Jane as Detective Chilmark
202218½ as Paul
2022Super Pumped: The Battle for Uber (1 Episode) as John Zimmer
2021The Many Saints of Newark as Silvio Dante
2021Lansky as Young Meyer Lansky
2021The Birthday Cake as Cousin Joey
2020First Cow: A Place in This World as Self
2020Talking Sopranos (1 Episode) as Self
2020First Cow as Cookie
2020Sylvie's Love as Sid
2019The Umbrella Academy (10 Episodes) as Leonard Peabody
2018Overlord as Private First Class Lyle Tibbet
2018Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan (3 Episodes) as Victor Polizzi
2017Marshall as Irwin Friedman
2017War Machine as Cory Staggart
2016Crisis in Six Scenes (6 Episodes) as Alan Brockman
2016Don't Worry Baby as Robert Lang
2016The Finest Hours as Ervin Maske
2016Angie Tribeca (1 Episode) as Snick
2015The Big Short as Charlie Geller
2015Carol as Dannie McElroy
2014Unbroken as Frank A. Tinker
2013Orange Is the New Black (11 Episodes) as Vince Muccio
2013Deep Powder as Cota
2012Not Fade Away as Douglas Damiano
2012Liberal Arts as Dean
2011Person of Interest (1 Episode) as Carl Elias (Age 22)
2011Body of Proof (1 Episode) as Chuck Foster
2011Down the Shore as Martin
2010My Soul to Take as Alex
2009The Box as Charles
2009The Good Wife (3 Episodes) as Roland Hlavin
2009Taking Chance as Rich Brewer
2008Assassination of a High School President as Cipriato
2007The Brave One as Ethan
2007The Life Before Her Eyes as Michael Patrick
2007Bomb as Unknown
2006Conviction (1 Episode) as Jiggy
1999Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1, 1 Episode) as Andrew Hingham, Keith Musio
1990Law & Order (1 Episode) as Nathan Gersh
1953The Oscars (1 Episode) as Self
TBASilk ... Director
2025Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer ... Executive Producer
2023Tender ... Producer
2022Private Property ... Thanks